Q
Anonymous asked:
I've played plenty of games in my life with high skill ceilings, but every once in a while when I play the first hour of a game I'll stop and gawk knowing I'm performing well below what the game can ultimately allow. It's intimidating/discouraging sometimes! What do you think might lead to that? As opposed to the plenty of other games where it feels much easier to slowly practice into competency?
A
It’s mentally discouraging if you can’t see a path to get to your goal from where you currently are. Much of human growth as we grow and mature is learning how to “operationalize” - how to break down large seemingly-impossible tasks into smaller, doable tasks. For a small child that might be learning that “clean your room” actually means “put your toys in the toy chest, put your shirts in this drawer, put your pants in this drawer, and make your bed”. Before understanding that breakdown, “clean your room” might be an impossible task for the child.
Similarly with games, it can be incredibly daunting to see a huge gap in game skill and/or performance because you haven’t yet learned how to operationalize the tasks needed to perform at that level yet. Depending on how much grit (the “not giving up” quality) the player has, that can either be the end of it or it can be the point of catharsis for the player to figure out how to get to where she wants to be. As we learn these skills and figure out how they fit and work together, the overall goal should become more and more practically achievable. As designers, we generally try to avoid creating experiences where skill gaps are shown so visibly for just that reason - we don’t want players to give up before things get fun - but there’s also that tradeoff of players wanting to see just how cool and awesome a thing can be at its highest potential.
[Join us on Discord] and/or [Support us on Patreon]
Got a burning question you want answered?
- Short questions: Ask a Game Dev on Twitter
- Long questions: Ask a Game Dev on Tumblr
- Frequent Questions: The FAQ
Notes
wolffyluna liked this swirlingflight reblogged this from theothin
luccianobs liked this
richardtrevisani liked this nettacki liked this
madameevil liked this
supercomputer276 reblogged this from askagamedev
space-wizards reblogged this from theothin
ursopanda liked this
isayoldbean liked this
tabbycatsdream liked this
chride liked this saccharine-tar reblogged this from jadedresearcher
heliumite-josie liked this
ilikemartletfromuty reblogged this from sobredunia
sobredunia reblogged this from sansxfuckyou
sansxfuckyou reblogged this from jadedresearcher jadedresearcher reblogged this from theothin
bird-cannibalism reblogged this from askagamedev
just-mango liked this fleabag liked this
theothin reblogged this from askagamedev
postalpacalypticllamas liked this
de-sterren-nacht liked this
theskyexists liked this
askagamedev posted this I've played plenty of games in my life with high skill ceilings, but every once in a while when I play the first hour of...